Judging The Movie

Acharei Mot – Kedoshim:

I recently had the opportunity to revisit the excellent book ‘The Other Side of The Story’. It is written by Mrs Yehudis Samet who for many years has led workshops dealing with the topic of judging people favorably. The book lays out many lessons and techniques regarding this important area, and brings personal stories that the ladies in the workshop shared throughout the process.
 
The following situation happened to Mrs Samet herself. Here is the story, in her own words:
 
“We were on vacation and I went into the local supermarket to pick up a few things we needed. My husband was waiting in the car, so I went up and down the aisles as fast as I could. I was wearing a sweater and felt a little warm, so I put my sweater in the cart, too. I checked my groceries through with the cashier, she bagged them, and then I put them back into the cart and wheeled the cart out to the parking lot where my husband was parked.
 
“As we were putting the bags of groceries into the car, I picked up my sweater and there was a jar of coffee and a can of herring, worth about $10 in the cart. Apparently I had not noticed them under the sweater and had not put them on the counter to be checked out.
 
“I walked back into the store and found the cashier. I held up the herring and the coffee and said, ‘I’m so very sorry. I found these under my sweater and I never paid for them.’
 
“While she was ringing up the items, the checkout girl looked at me and smiled. ‘You didn’t see those two ladies behind you, did you, ma’am?’
 
“‘Two ladies?’
 
“‘Yes, they were standing behind you, whispering and laughing about you. I didn’t know what they were laughing about, but it sure makes sense now. They must have seen those things peeking out from under your sweater.’
 
“These women had already left the store and never saw me come back to pay for the forgotten items. I don’t know who those women were, but they surely thought they were witnessing a crime with their own eyes. How humiliating to be mistaken for a thief.
 
“Now if somebody comes and tells me a story, even if they say, ‘Of course it’s true, I saw it with my own eyes.’ I know it still may not be the true story.”
 
The concept of judging favorably/giving people the benefit of the doubt, is learnt from the words in this week’s Parsha, בצדק תשפט עמיתך, ‘with righteousness shall you judge your fellow’. Apart from the straightforward explanation – an instruction for a judge to rule truthfully – the Sages understood this to mean that each one of us should not automatically leap to negative conclusions when we see someone doing something that appears wrong. Is there perhaps a different explanation, something that we are missing from the full picture?
 
Rabbi Nachman of Breslov says that judging favorably is crucial for our own wellbeing. He explains that before G-d brings upon a person the consequences of their negative actions, He first consults the person’s own soul. Only if the soul agrees they it should be punished, will G-d move ahead with the retribution. The question we should ask though is, if the soul has the final say, why would the soul agree and bring suffering upon itself?
 
Explains Rabbi Nachman: The soul is presented with the case as if someone else carried out the action. It watches as someone else goes and transgresses and then it is asked, ‘what should happen to someone who did that’. When the soul announces, ‘Well, it is clear that that was wrong and they should get the punishment that the Torah prescribes’, the soul is then told, ‘Actually, it was you who did that’.
 
But consider this. If a person has got used to giving the benefit of the doubt, understanding that what they see isn’t always the full story, that there are many challenges that people have, struggles and baggage that can weigh down and make simple actions very difficult, then when their soul is presented with the ‘movie’, it will naturally search out for a positive view of the leading character. It will gives excuses as to why perhaps this person should not be punished – and then G-d will say, as you saw the good in this person, I will treat you the same way.
 
So let’s get practicing right now! Let’s train ourselves so that our kneejerk reaction to seeing something wrong is, ‘perhaps I don’t understand the situation fully’ and this will stand us in good stead when the tables are turned on us.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *